top of page

What the Workday Lawsuit Means for Job Seekers Over 40

21 hours ago
4 min read

Every employer sets up its software differently. The decision still belongs to a person.

You've applied to role after role you're qualified for. Some rejections come back within hours. Others never come at all. If you're over 40, you've probably wondered whether a person ever looked at your application. The Workday lawsuit has put a version of that question before a federal judge, and it's worth understanding what the case does and doesn't mean for your search.

Where the Workday Lawsuit Stands

The case is Mobley v. Workday, filed in federal court in Northern California. Job seekers over 40 allege that Workday's AI-based screening tools, which many employers use to sort applicants, disproportionately screened out older applicants. Workday denies that its recruiting technology unlawfully discriminates and is contesting the case. No court has found that it does.

On November 10, 2026, Workday asked the judge to decertify that group, arguing that the people who joined aren't similarly situated. The court hasn't ruled. A hearing on the plaintiffs' separate motion for class certification is set for March 9, 2027.

Workday's Own Argument Tells You Something

Here's the part I want every job seeker to notice. Workday's position rests on the point that each employer configures and uses the platform differently, sets its own hiring requirements, and makes its own hiring decisions.

Whatever the court decides, take that at face value. If every company sets up its system its own way, there's no single trick that beats every system. The keyword hack that worked at one company may do nothing at the next. The formatting rule you read about online may have been written for software you'll never encounter.

That's what it costs you: hours spent tuning a resume for a machine you can't see, while the thing that actually decides the outcome goes untouched.

A hiring manager at his desk, reading a printed resume closely

What Gets a Resume Read

What works doesn't depend on any one system. A resume has to be clean enough for the software to read it correctly, and strong enough in results that the person who opens it keeps reading.

Both halves matter. If the software can't read it due to formatting errors or improper enhancements, nobody sees it. If a person opens it and finds a list of duties instead of outcomes, they move on, and your 20 years of experience reads as just 20 years. For professionals over 40, that second failure is the expensive one. A long career tends to produce a long resume, and the results a hiring manager wants get buried under everything else.

Book a complimentary meeting with me, and I'll review your resume with you and tell you exactly what's keeping it from getting read.

Choose a time that works best for you.

What I Saw From the Recruiter's Chair

I spent 20 years as an executive recruiter, from 1995 through 2015. Applicant tracking systems (ATS) were already part of hiring then.

My process was straightforward. I sourced candidates myself, interviewed them, and then verbally presented their backgrounds to the hiring authority before a resume was ever submitted. After sending resumes or providing candidates' names, I sometimes received a callback saying that the candidate was already in their system. They had been sitting there for months, sometimes up to a year, yet no one had reached out to them.

These were strong candidates. Once a decision-maker understood their capabilities, the company was eager to talk to them. Imagine that the system had access to these candidates all along but missed the opportunity because, unlike me, it couldn't ask any questions. It merely scans resumes against job descriptions and ranks them based on how well they match.

I took that lesson with me when I founded Soar Career Services in 2016. Software can hold your application, but it can't decide to hire you.

The screening tools have changed since then. Today, employers can use AI tools, like the ones at the center of this lawsuit, to score, sort, and rank applicants. Those tools can't ask why you made a career move, hear the story behind a promotion, or weigh what two decades of results are worth. A person can.

That's why getting past the software is only half the job. Your resume has to do for you what I used to do on the phone for the candidates I sourced: tell the person reading it, quickly and clearly, why you're worth the conversation.

A recruiter on a desk phone presenting a candidate, with handwritten notes in front of her

A Person Makes the Decision

Whatever happens in the Workday lawsuit, one thing won't change. Even Workday's own argument says the hiring decision belongs to the employer, and that means a person. Your job is to get in front of that person with a resume that captures their attention within the first 6 to 10 seconds!

Your experience is an asset. Make sure the people who decide get to see it.

If you've been applying and hearing nothing back, let's find out why. Book a complimentary meeting with me, and I'll walk through your resume with you the way a hiring manager reads it. You'll leave knowing exactly what the person on the other side sees in those first few seconds, and what's keeping them from picking up the phone.

Choose a time that works best for you.

Bobbiette Swanson is the founder of Soar Career Services, which she launched in 2016 after twenty years as an award-winning Certified Senior Executive Recruiter and nearly three decades in careers and hiring. She writes executive resumes, optimizes LinkedIn profiles, and coaches senior professionals through career transitions, drawing on best practices across multiple industries. She leads the writing and strategy for every client engagement.

Comments


bottom of page